Gift agreement – when necessary and why

Gifts are a common form of asset transfer in everyday life, whether for family reasons or out of pure friendship. Under German law, gifts are defined in Section 516 of the Civil Code (BGB) as gratuitous transfers in which the donor transfers an asset from their estate to the recipient without receiving anything in return.

A gift agreement serves as a legal basis and safeguard for both parties, helping to avoid disputes and create transparency.

In order to process a donation in a legally compliant and proper manner, it is essential to be familiar with and observe the current laws, regulations, and court rulings.

New: Create a customized gift agreement easily with our tool: https://beglaubigt.de/schenkungsvertrag

The following article provides a detailed and in-depth insight into the subject of gift agreements and explains when they are necessary and why. In this context, reference is also made to the document generator from Beglaubigt.de, which generates legally compliant contracts quickly as PDF or Word documents.

A gift agreement may be necessary in the following situations, for example:

• Donation of real estate or land
• Valuable art objects or antiques
• Gift agreement for a horse
• Gift agreement for a car
• Transfer of company shares

Current laws, paragraphs, and court rulings are cited in order to provide the best possible information and enable a well-founded insight into the topic. For example, reference is made to §§ 516 - 534 BGB, which represent the legal basis for gifts and gift agreements.

Through an objective, detailed, and in-depth analysis of the topic, an informed decision should be made regarding the necessity of a gift agreement and possible legal pitfalls should be avoided.

Why a gift agreement?

A gift agreement is important and useful for various reasons:

• Legal certainty: A documented gift agreement guarantees clarity and legal certainty. By precisely defining the terms and scope of the gift, subsequent conflicts or misunderstandings can be avoided.
• Freedom of design: The gift agreement allows the donor to specify individual conditions, such as special requirements or rights of recovery. This gives the donor flexibility and control over the design of the gift.
• Tax advantages: The gift agreement can be used to obtain tax benefits, particularly in the area of inheritance tax. Early asset transfers allow you to take advantage of tax allowances and minimize your tax burden. The agreement also serves as proof for the tax office.
• Early transfer of assets: A gift agreement enables the targeted transfer of assets during the donor's lifetime. This facilitates early settlement of the estate and can minimize inheritance disputes.
• Legal requirements: For the transfer of certain assets, such as real estate, a gift agreement is legally required, often including notarization, in order to make the gift legally valid.
  

Overall, a gift agreement offers numerous advantages for both the donor and the recipient. It ensures the legal security of the gift, allows for individual customization, and may offer tax advantages under certain circumstances. It is recommended to seek expert advice on gifts in order to avoid potential mistakes and pitfalls.

When is a gift agreement necessary?

A gift agreement is necessary when assets or rights are transferred free of charge from one person (the donor) to another person (the recipient). The necessity of a gift agreement depends on various factors, in particular the type of asset and the legal requirements applicable to the gift. The following are some situations in which a gift agreement is required:

1. Real estate transfer: When donating land or real estate, a notarized donation agreement is required in accordance with Section 311b (1) sentence 1 of the German Civil Code (BGB). This ensures that the donation is legally valid and that both parties are informed of their rights and obligations in connection with the donation.
2. Valuable assets: When donating valuable assets such as works of art, antiques, or jewelry, it is advisable to conclude a donation agreement in order to prevent any ambiguities or disputes. Although there are no legal formal requirements for this type of donation, a written agreement can provide clarity and security for both parties.
3. Vehicle transfer: When donating a motor vehicle, it is advisable to conclude a donation agreement in order to document the transfer of ownership and facilitate re-registration with the registration authority. A written agreement should include the vehicle identification number, mileage, and all relevant information about the vehicle.
4. Transfer of company shares: If company shares or stocks are gifted, a gift agreement is required to regulate the transfer of ownership and take into account possible tax consequences. Depending on the legal form of the company, different requirements may apply to the agreement.
5. Gifts with conditions or requirements: In cases where the donor attaches certain conditions or requirements to the gift, a gift agreement should be concluded to ensure compliance with these conditions or requirements and to secure the legal position of the donor.
   

Gift agreement – when is it necessary and why? What are the advantages?

The advantages of a gift agreement are manifold and include, among other things:

1. Legal certainty: A written gift agreement provides legal certainty for both the donor and the recipient by clearly and unambiguously defining the terms and scope of the gift, thereby preventing future disputes or misunderstandings.
2. Design options: A gift agreement allows the donor to agree on certain requirements, conditions, or rights of recovery, enabling the gift to be customized and giving the donor more control over how the gifted assets are used.
3. Tax advantages: A gift can offer tax advantages, particularly with regard to inheritance tax. Transferring assets early allows you to take advantage of tax allowances and can lead to tax savings. A gift agreement documents the gift and supports compliance with tax requirements.
4. Transfer of assets during your lifetime: A gift agreement allows you to transfer assets to the next generation or to third parties during your lifetime. This helps to settle your estate at an early stage and avoid potential inheritance disputes.
5. Compliance with legal requirements: In some cases, a gift agreement is required by law, for example, when donating real estate or land. In such cases, notarization is required to make the gift legally valid.
   

Gift agreement – When necessary: A case study

A gift agreement is necessary and advantageous in order to ensure legal certainty in the transfer of assets and to enable individual structuring options. An example of this is the gift of a house from parents to their child:

Mr. and Mrs. Müller want to gift their house to their son, Michael, so that he can take ownership during their lifetime and they can take advantage of tax benefits. To ensure that the gift is legally binding and to retain the option of reclaiming the house if certain conditions are met, the Müllers decide to draw up a gift agreement.

The deed of gift clearly and unambiguously specifies the scope of the gift and the conditions under which the house is transferred.

In the contract, the Müllers agree, for example, on a right of recovery in the event that they themselves fall into financial hardship or their son becomes grossly ungrateful towards them. In addition, the contract may contain a usage restriction stipulating that the house may only be occupied by Michael and his family.

Since this is a real estate gift, notarization of the gift contract is required by law. After notarization and entry in the land register, the gift becomes effective and Michael is the new owner of the house.

The gift agreement provides legal certainty for the transfer of assets, takes into account individual options such as rights of recovery and conditions, and allows tax advantages such as the use of allowances to be exploited to the full.

How does the tax office find out about a gift?

The tax office usually learns of a gift through the fulfillment of the legal reporting obligations of the parties involved. According to tax regulations, both the donor and the recipient are required to report a gift to the relevant tax office if certain value limits are exceeded.

Here are some ways in which the tax office can find out about a gift:

1. Self-reporting by the parties involved: The donor and/or recipient report the gift to the tax office within the specified time limit. As a rule, the relevant forms must be completed and submitted in order to provide all relevant information about the gift.
2. Notarization: In the case of notarized gifts, such as the transfer of real estate, the notary usually automatically informs the tax office about the gift. However, the parties involved should ensure that they fulfill their own reporting obligations.
3. Entries in the land register: When land or real estate is gifted, this is usually recorded in the land register. As the land register is publicly accessible, the tax office can also find out about the gift in this way.
4. Information from third parties: In some cases, the tax office may also be informed of a gift through information provided by third parties, such as banks or insurance companies.

It is essential to comply with the legal reporting requirements for gifts and to report the gift to the tax office in good time. Otherwise, you may face additional tax payments, late payment penalties, or even fines.

New: Create a customized gift agreement easily with our tool: https://beglaubigt.de/schenkungsvertrag

Is a gift without a contract valid?

A gift without a contract may be valid under certain circumstances. It depends on the type of asset and the legal requirements. As a general rule, gifts can be made without any formal requirements, as long as there are no specific formal requirements.

This means that a gift can also be made verbally, through conclusive action, or even by simply handing over the item. However, there are exceptions where a specific form is required to make the gift legally valid.

1. Informal gifts: Most gifts of movable property, such as furniture, clothing, or household items, do not require any special formality. Such gifts can be valid without a contract if the donor transfers possession of the item to the recipient and both parties agree to make a gift.
2. Gifts requiring a specific form: In certain cases, the law stipulates a specific form for gifts. The best-known formal requirement concerns the gift of land or real estate. According to Section 311b (1) sentence 1 of the German Civil Code (BGB), a notarized gift agreement is required for this purpose. Without notarization, the gift is not valid.

There is another formal requirement for the donation of vehicles. Even if a written contract is not mandatory, the vehicle must be re-registered with the registration authority in order to legally secure the donation.

It should be noted that although a gift without a contract may be valid in some cases, a written contract offers the parties greater security and clarity. In the case of valuable assets or complex gifts, it is therefore advisable to conclude a gift contract in order to avoid potential disputes or ambiguities and to record the rights and obligations of both parties.

More on this topic is provided in a more detailed article: When is a gift agreement valid?

Is it possible to make a gift without a notary?

In many cases, it is possible to make a gift without a notary, as there are no legal formal requirements for most gifts. However, there are certain situations in which notarization is required to make the gift legally valid. The differences between gifts that can be made without a notary and those that require notarization are explained below.

1. Gifts without a notary: For most gifts, especially movable property such as furniture, household items, or clothing, no special form is required. These gifts can be made verbally, through conclusive action, or by simply handing over the item, without the need to involve a notary. The donation of vehicles also does not usually require notarization, although a written contract is recommended to document the transfer of ownership.
2. Gifts requiring notarization: In certain cases, notarization is required by law for a gift to be valid. The most common situation in which a notary is required is the gift of land or real estate. According to Section 311b (1) sentence 1 of the German Civil Code (BGB), the gift agreement must be notarized in order for the gift to be legally valid. Without notarization, the gift of real estate is invalid.

Notarization may also be required for the transfer of company shares or stocks. This depends on the legal form of the company and the relevant legal provisions.

In summary, it can be said that in many cases it is possible to make a gift without a notary. However, it is important to take into account the legal requirements and the type of asset in order to ensure that the gift is legally valid. In situations where notarization is required, care should be taken to comply with the formal requirements in order to ensure the validity of the gift.

How does the tax office know about a gift?

The tax office can find out about a gift in various ways. Here are some of the most common ways in which the tax office is informed about gifts:

1. Recipient's obligation to report: According to Section 30 of the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act (ErbStG), the recipient is obliged to report a gift to the relevant tax office within a period of three months. This reporting obligation applies regardless of whether the gift is taxable or not. Failure to comply with this obligation may result in fines.
2. Notary: In the case of gifts that require notarization, such as gifts of real estate, the notary is obliged to notify the tax office of the gift. This is usually done by the notary sending a copy of the gift agreement to the relevant tax office.
3. Banks and other financial institutions: When bank balances, securities, or shares are gifted, the tax office may be informed by the banks or financial institutions involved. In many cases, these institutions are legally obliged to report certain transactions to the tax authorities.
4. Offices and authorities: In the case of gifts that require a change of registration or amendment to the land register, such as gifts of real estate or vehicles, the relevant offices and authorities may inform the tax office of the gift.
5. Self-disclosure by the donor: The donor can also voluntarily inform the tax office about the gift, especially if they believe that the gift could have tax implications. This can help to avoid subsequent ambiguities or possible additional tax claims.

The experts at Beglaubigt.de recommend complying with the legal reporting requirements relating to gifts in order to avoid possible fines or additional tax claims. In addition, you should find out about possible tax exemptions and allowances in order to optimize the tax treatment of the gift.

Under what circumstances is a contribution not considered a gift?

A gift is defined as the transfer without consideration of an asset or right from one person (the donor) to another (the donee) with the intention of enrichment. However, there are situations in which a supposed gift is not legally classified as such:

• Contracts for consideration: If the recipient provides consideration for the asset or right received, it is not a gift but a contract for consideration, such as a purchase or exchange contract.
• Anticipation of a gift: A promise to give a gift constitutes a binding commitment to make a gift in the future. However, this promise alone does not result in a gift; it requires a further expression of intent by the donor to make the gift legally valid.
• Loan agreements: In the case of a loan, an asset or right is only transferred for temporary use. Since there is no permanent transfer and the object or right must be returned, this does not constitute a gift.
• Assumption of costs out of moral obligation: If someone voluntarily assumes costs for another person out of moral obligation or for reasons of charity, such as financing a funeral, this is not legally considered a gift, as there is no intention to enrich oneself.
• Void gifts: Under certain circumstances, a gift may be void, for example in the case of formal defects (e.g., lack of notarization in the case of real estate transfers) or contestation (e.g., due to fraud or error). In these cases, the gift is not legally accepted.

Understanding the distinctions between a gift and other legal relationships is important in order to understand the respective legal consequences and obligations.

What are some common mistakes and pitfalls in gift agreements?

Various errors and pitfalls can arise in gift agreements, which can lead to legal and tax problems. Here are some common errors and pitfalls:

1. Insufficient or incorrect contract details: A gift agreement should contain all relevant information and conditions to ensure legal certainty. Unclear or missing information can lead to misunderstandings and disputes. It is therefore important to draft the contract carefully and completely.
2. Failure to have the contract notarized: In certain cases, such as the transfer of real estate or land, notarization of the gift agreement is required by law. Failure to have such a contract notarized may result in the gift being invalid.
3. Failure to comply with deadlines and formalities: Gifts are often subject to certain deadlines and formalities, for example with regard to tax reporting obligations or entry in the land register. Failure to comply with these requirements can lead to legal problems and possibly financial disadvantages.
4. Failure to report for tax purposes: Gifts may have to be reported to the tax office, especially if certain value limits are exceeded. Failure to comply with this reporting obligation may result in additional tax payments and penalties.
5. Misunderstandings about rights of recovery: In the case of a gift, the donor may agree on rights of recovery under certain conditions. However, if these rights are not correctly anchored in the gift agreement, they may be invalid or lead to disputes.
6. Lack of knowledge of tax allowances and regulations: Gift tax is subject to various allowances and regulations based on the degree of kinship between the parties involved and the value of the gift. Insufficient knowledge of these regulations can lead to unfavorable tax treatment of the gift.
   

What legal requirements must be observed?

Legal basis for gifts in Germany

A gift is a voluntary, gratuitous transfer of assets from one person (the donor) to another person (the recipient). In Germany, both civil and tax law regulations must be observed in this regard.

1. Civil law regulations: Civil Code (BGB)

The German Civil Code (BGB) defines a gift in Section 516 as a contract whereby one person enriches another from their own assets and both parties agree that the gift is made free of charge.

Some important provisions in the German Civil Code (BGB) regarding gifts are:

• Form of the gift (Section 518 BGB): In principle, a gift can be made without any formal requirements. However, certain gifts, such as real estate, require notarization.
• Revocation of a gift (Section 530 BGB): Under certain circumstances, the donor may revoke the gift, e.g. if he has grounds for complaint due to serious misconduct on the part of the recipient.
• Compulsory portion and gifts (Section 2325 BGB): If the donor dies within 10 years of making the gift, the gift may be taken into account when calculating the heir's compulsory portion.
• Impossibility of performance and promise of gift (§§ 523, 524 BGB): If the promised gift is no longer possible or the promise of gift is not fulfilled, there are provisions for reclamation or claims for damages.

2. Tax regulations: Inheritance Tax and Gift Tax Act (ErbStG)

Gift tax may be payable on the transfer of assets. The German Inheritance Tax Act (ErbStG) regulates the taxation of acquisitions through gifts or inheritance.

Some key aspects of the ErbStG:

• Exemptions: There are certain exemptions up to which no gift tax is payable. These vary depending on the degree of kinship between the donor and the recipient. For example, spouses and registered partners have an allowance of $500,000, children $400,000, and grandchildren $200,000.
• Tax classes: Different tax rates apply depending on the degree of kinship.
• Exemption rules: For certain types of assets, such as business assets, there may be exemption rules that can reduce the tax burden.
• Ten-year rule: If less than ten years elapse between two gifts to the same recipient, these gifts are added together and may affect the tax allowances.

Which is better: transfer or gift?

Whether a transfer or a gift is the better option depends on the individual circumstances and goals of the people involved. Both approaches have advantages and disadvantages that should be considered when making a decision. The following section compares some aspects of transfers and gifts to help you make your decision:

1. Tax stuff: If you give someone something as a gift, you might have to pay gift tax and maybe even real estate transfer tax. But there are some tax breaks that change depending on how close you are to the person and can be used again every ten years. In the case of a transfer for consideration, for example as part of a purchase agreement, real estate transfer tax is payable and, in some cases, income tax on the profit generated. It is important to carefully examine the tax implications of both options and, if necessary, consult a tax advisor.
   
2. Restrictions on disposal: In the case of a gift, the donor may stipulate restrictions on disposal or rights of recovery in the gift agreement in order to recover the asset if necessary, for example in the event of a significant deterioration in the donor's financial circumstances. In the case of a transfer for consideration, such restrictions on disposal are generally not possible.
3. Claims to a compulsory portion supplement: In the case of a gift, claims to a compulsory portion supplement may arise if the donor dies and the gift was made within the last ten years prior to death. In this case, the beneficiaries of the compulsory portion must be taken into account, and a claim for repayment or a payment obligation may arise. In the case of a transfer for consideration, claims for supplementary compulsory portions are generally excluded.
   
4. Reserved rights of use: In the case of a gift, the donor may agree on a lifelong right of residence or a right of usufruct in the gift agreement in order to secure the use of the transferred asset for themselves. In the case of a transfer in return for payment, this is generally not possible.

There is no blanket answer as to whether a transfer or a gift is better. The individual circumstances, goals, and needs of the persons involved must be taken into account, as well as the legal and tax consequences of both options.

Summary and conclusion: Gift agreement – necessity and advantages

A gift agreement is required under certain conditions in order to process a gift in a legally secure manner. It is essential, especially for real estate gifts or asset transfers that require notarization. While gifts are legally valid even without a contract in some cases, this often entails legal risks. Notarization is generally not required for gifts of money or movable property.

The tax office is informed about gifts in various ways, for example through the recipient's obligation to report them, notifications from notaries, or financial institutions. It is therefore essential to find out about the tax implications and reporting obligations in advance.

A gift is not considered genuine if there is consideration in return, if it is a loan, or if the gift is revoked. When choosing between a gift and a transfer, individual factors and tax aspects should be taken into account.

A gift agreement offers numerous advantages. It allows specific clauses to be stipulated, such as restrictions on disposal or reserved rights of use, and enables tax advantages to be exploited. It also ensures legal clarity between the contracting parties.